THE TOMBS OF ATUAN BY URSULA K. LE GUIN (BOOK REVIEW + 4 SUMMER OUTFITS)
Hello, readers and fellow bloggers! In this post, I'll review The Tombs of Atuan, a novel by Urusla K. Le Guin. Published in 1970, this fantasy bildungsroman is the second novel in the famous Earthsea series, but the first one to feature a female protagonist. Just with its prequel, the reviews and the critique for this novel have been mostly positive and the book was on overall well received. The Earthsea saga has won many awards and it continues to win hearts! Besides book reviewing, today I'll also show you four Mostar summer nights outfits.
The Tombs of Atuan
In the deep valley, in the twilight, the apple trees were on the eve of blossoming; here and there among the shadowed boughs one flower had opened early, rose and white, like a faint star. Down the orchard aisles, in the thick, new, wet grass, the little girl ran for the joy of running; hearing the call she did not come at once, but made a long circle before she turned her face toward home. The mother waiting in the doorway of the hut, with the firelight behind her, watched the tiny figure running and bobbing like a bit of thistledown blown over the darkening grass beneath the trees.”
TENAR IS RAISED TO BECOME THE HIGH PRISTESS OF THE NAMELESS ONES
It is because Tenar was born on the day that the high priestess of the Tombs of Atuan died, that she is believed to be her reincarnation. The belief is quite strong among everyone, and eventually Tenar starts to believe it herself.
Tenar is taken from her family when she is but five years old. At age six she undergoes this symbolic sacrifice. Up until that point, she's lived with other girls but she was still separated from them because of her future role. Tenar's name is taken from her in a ceremony, and from that moment she is referred to as Arha, and that means- the eaten one. They believe her previous identity has been eaten and now she is nothing but a reincarnation of the main priestess. They don't expect her to take on her role just yet, so she's in an unusual position- a very lonely position.
Being the child she is, Tenar is rather powerless and lonely. As readers, we basically see her grow up in a cult like setting. She doesn't question the things she is told, because she has no reference point, she literally knows nothing about the life outside the tombs and the convent. I found the way Tenar was written very convincing.
TENAR'S CHILDHOOD IS EXTREMELY LONESOME AND SAD
While Tenar is never physically punished like the other girls who are to become priestesses, she certainly isn't given much freedom. Tenar always has duties and chores to do- not different from others. However, she's definitely more lonely and isolated than other girls.
Tenar is moved into her own house after the ceremony. She's not left completely without affection, for she is given an eunuch servant, Manan, who genuinely cares about her and seems to understand that she's just a child. He's the only person who treats her as a child who needs affection and he tries to care for her. You could say he's the only adult on whom Tenar can rely. The others just want her to become the main priestess. While Tenar feels a sense of satisfaction knowing that most have to knock on her doors before entering, before Thar and Kossil, she understands she has no real power.
IRONICALLY, TENAR THE HEAD PRIESTESS IS PORTRAYED AS HAVING NO POWER
Ursula herself explained how Tenar doesn't really have any power, even when she is proclaimed the main priestess.
“In The Tombs of Atuan, the Old Powers, the Nameless Ones, appear as mysterious, ominous, and yet inactive. Arha/Tenar is their priestess, the greatest of all priestesses, whom the Godking himself is supposed to obey: But what is her realm? A prison in the desert. Women guarded by eunuchs. Ancient tombstones, a half-ruined temple, an empty throne. A fearful underground labyrinth where prisoners are left to die of starvation and thirst, where only she can walk the maze, where light must never come. She rules a dark, empty, useless realm. Her power imprisons her. This isn’t the rosy reassurance many novels at the time offered adolescents. It’s a very bleak picture of what a girl may expect. Arha’s life is dreary, unchanging, with almost no experience of kindness except from Manan the eunuch. The third chapter may be the cruelest, most hopeless passage in all the Earthsea books. By consenting to the death of “her” prisoners, Arha locks the prison door upon herself. Her whole life will be lived in a trap.”
As I described Tenar's childhood is lonely and sad. However, her youth is even more lonely. Besides Manan, her only friend is a Penthe, a priestess who is her own age. Penthe shocks Tenar with her unbelief in the gods, especially the God-king. Penthe is presented as simple girl who is in contrast to everyone- full of life. Penthe didn't become a priestess of her own will. She wanted to be a dancer. Tenar is absolutely shocked when she learns of Penthe's unbelief, and as reader you can see that it's the first time the thought of questioning the things she knows ever enters her head.
“She had not realized how very different people were, how differently they saw life. She felt as if she had looked up and suddenly seen a whole new planet hanging huge and populous right outside the window, an entirely strange world, one in which the gods did not matter.”
Tenar receives training, mostly from Thar and Kossil. Who are these two? They are the priestesses of different Gods actually, and don't get along as well as it seems. Thar serves the same Gods as Tenar, while Kossil serves the so called 'God-king'. As the story progresses, we realizes that the God-king doesn't like sharing power, nor does his priestess Kossil.
Thar often refers to her past conversations that Tenar supposedly had with Thar in her past life as the main priestess. Supposedly, when Tenar was the main priestess, she told Thar about the way of the tombs. Thair now repeats their supposed past conversations, basically teaching Tenar about the tombs. Thar tells Tenar of the vast spaces of the undertomb and the labyrinth beneath the Tombs. Tenar has to learn everything by heart, following just oral instruction.
The priestesses don't use drawings, maps or writing, they just recite instructions. Thair describes the ancient treasure hidden within the labyrinth. She informs Tenar that wizards from the archipelago have tried to steal the treasure and this is the first time Tenar hears about the wizards.
In this land and culture, wizards are considered wicked, and even reading is considered a black art or witchcraft. Once Tenar turns fourteen, she assumes comes into her role- and becomes the highest ranked priestess in the Tombs. However, Tenar is more lonely as well. The only freedom she has is to roam the undertombs in the dark by herself.
Naturally, initially Tenar is terrified, but with time Tenar starts exploring the labyrinth and the undertombs, the only places where she can be free. Ursula wrote Tenar in this way because she wanted her to be credible. Even with her high title, Tenar is a little more than a slave: "She couldn’t be a hero in the hero-tale sense. Not even in a fantasy? No. Because to me, fantasy isn’t wishful thinking, but a way of reflecting, and reflecting on reality.”
THE PORTRAYAL OF CHARACTERS IS SO WELL DONE
Ursula K. Le Guin is quite economic and descriptive with her words. I found it very impressive how the writer can accurately portray someone with just a few well selected sentences. The story is focused on Tenar, but the minor characters seem so real. The characters Tenar interacts the most are so well portrayed. With just a few words, Ursula K. Le Guin has painted just a touching portrayal of Manan, the eunich servant that becomes a fatherly figure for Tenar. Manan is a simple man of no education, but as a reader you get the feeling that he has gained wisdom through suffering. Tenar's young friend is a very credible girl as well. The two priestesses of the main Gods are well portrayed as well. Le Guin often relies on dialogues in order to portray her characters, letting them reveal things about themselves through their own words. I quite admire how she is able to put forward a lot of information without relying on lengthily descriptions.
“Her boredom rose so strong in her sometimes that it felt like terror: it took her by the throat. Not long ago she had been driven to speak of it. She had to talk, she thought, or she would go mad.”
THE WORLD BUILDING IS VERY CONVIENCING AS WELL
Throughout the series, the world- building is well done. In this book, I felt like we were introduced to a different world almost, but still one that belongs to the Earthsea Universe. Since the Earthsea world is basically an archipelago (as you can see in the maps), the cultures and nations on it develop quite independently. So, as readers we're gradually introduced to the culture of Atuan and the cults/religions there present. We're learning about this world through Tenar's eyes.
What are exactly duties of a the high priestess? Even after she becomes the high priestess, Tenar has to perform rituals and work like everyone else there. Her life is anything but easy. It's often stated that everyone present has to pull their weight. There's much physical work to do. Does this mean that the priestesses are not that revealed or loved? They live far away from others, and the general population doesn't seem to give them gifts nor does the God-king sends gifts. The only gift he seems to send are the prisoners.
LIFE DOESN'T GET EASIER FOR TENAR ONCE SHE BECOMES THE HIGH PRIESTESS
Which brings us to another 'sacred' duty Tenar has- is to determine the manner death of unbelievers. Who are the unbelievers? They are enemies of the so called God-king. Tenar jobs is to decide how they will be killed once they arrive. Not a very attractive duty, but Tenar accepts it because she was raised to believe that it will appraise the Nameless Ones. At this point, Tenar's faith in the Nameless One is sincere.
Who is this God-king? We're given clues as the story progresses. God-king is very powerful, more powerful than the priestesses, it seems. Tenar says it wasn't always so, and we time we can see Tenar growing resentment toward the God-king. Tenar notices that the place they live in seems rather shabby, while the one in which the Godking lives is more grand. It seems that the Godking only acknowledges the priestess out of tradition, and would like to get rid of them if possible. It is explained that the the kinds of the old started to take more and more power until they turned themselves into deities.
Tenar is young, bored, isolated and unhappy, but she is still filled with the sense of duty, and perhaps even a dose of pride because she believes the Nameless Ones to be very powerful and as their servant, that means she's powerful too. I think what draws Tenar to perceive the Nameless Ones that way is basically just her feeling out of control. Perhaps she hopes to get some power through connection to them. Now, that I think about it, isn't it often true? People develop belief systems and believe in them in order to feel less alone.
A DARK MOMENT AS TENAR HAS TO DECIDE THE MANNER OF PRISONERS' DEATH
Possibly the darkest moment in the book is when Tenar has to order the death of prisoners. Basically, she doesn't have the authority to set them free, but what she does will haunt her nevertheless. Tenar is a difficult position. Tenar is often kept in the dark- both in the literal and the metaphorical sense.
When Tenar is taken undertombs to meet the prisoners, she is told that no light is allowed. Tenar is supposed to be the head priestess and feels the responsibility on her shoulders. At the same time, Tenar is aware that there is much she doesn't know but is expected to, and she is too proud to reveal her weaknesses. Not that it would do her any good. In this dark world of what is basically a cult worship, everyone's knowledge is limited. Tenar is filled with fear as she struggles to orient herself in the dark- and this is true in both the metaphorical and literal way. Tenar has reason to literally be afraid for her life because if she gets lost in the undertombs, she will die. At the same times, the undertombs are supposed to be her domain and she feels a sense of freedom there, mingled with fear and disgust.
I mean she has been brought up in a pretty cruel way, so it's a miracle she's not completely crazy at this point. Tenar isn't cruel by nature, but when she is cornered, she commits an act of cruelty that will haunt her. This happens when she is taken undertombs and required to order the death of prisoners sent to the Tombs by the God-King of the Kargad lands. The way she goes under is very indicative, as describes she has to be led there, even if the is the main priestess because she is still to learn her way, and she has to be told things. This makes Tenar feel humiliated and she also feels humiliated by Kossil, who seems to dislike her.
Tenar is basically cornered into her role of an executioner. First, Tenar wants to speak with the man but learns that their tongues have been cut out. She commands them be killed by the eunuch servants not knowing that the man servants aren't allowed under. You can see her panic, as she considers what to do. I felt like she said the first thing that she taught of out of sheer panics. Tenar asks how they are fed and when she learns how, she says that they should simply stop lowering water and food to them. In other words, Tenars orders them to be starved to death.
I had a feeling she did it as much to save her face before others, as out of sheer panic. Isn't that often the case with humans? We act the rules that are imposed onto us, without questioning the casting. However, Tenar is not a cruel fanatic. While she never considers saving the men in earnest and accepts her role, this act torments and haunts Tenar. She falls ills and has terrible nightmare. Tenar basically experiences PTSD symbols and is tormented by the guilt, even if she doesn't rebel openly. Tenar suffers for a long time and I really felt sorry for this poor young girl who is, despite her high title, completely powerless.
THAR'S DEATH LEAVES TENAR EVEN MORE ISOLATED
As I explained, Thar has been preparing Tenar (presently called Arha) for this role, but nothing could prepare her for the deaths that will haunt her. Thar dies, and as far as we know it's from natural causes (old age) and this means that Tenar /Arha becomes not only more increasingly isolated and lonesome, but also vulnerable. Tenar is no fool and she acknowledges that Kossil hates her. Thar had been strict with Tenar, and while she didn't show her any mother lovely, she had been fair to her. On the other hand, Kossil hates her and doesn't even hide it that well. Kossil is the villan, one could say, she clearly sees the Nameless Ones as a threat to her and her God-kings' power. Certainly the cult of the Nameless Ones is not a theologically developed or merciful religion, but the more we learn about them, the more we feel bad as these women seem to be oppressed by the God-king. The priestesses of the Nameless Ones do not seem to be evil, even if what they do is not exactly good, one cannot see them as villains, simply because they have no power.
IN THIS DARK MOMENT, GED ARRIVES TO THE SCENE'No. It is one of the black arts.'
He nodded. 'But a useful one,' he said.”
The Tombs of Atuan
As, I said I'll show you 4 summer outfits I wore for nightly strolls in Mostar city.
“What she had begun to learn was the weight of liberty. Freedom is a heavy load, a great and strange burden for the spirit to undertake. It is not easy. It is not a gift given, but a choice made, and the choice may be a hard one. The road goes upward towards the light; but the laden traveler may never reach the end of it.”
THE TOMBS OF ATUAN BY URSULA K. LE GUIN
“How do I know," she said at last, "that you are what you seem to be?"
"You don't," Said he. "I don't know what I seem, to you.”
......
“...You have knowledge, and I have skill, and between us we have..."
"We have the Ring of Erreth-Akbe."
"Yes, that. But I thought also of another thing between us. Call it trust... That is one of its names. It is a very great thing. Though each of us alone is weak, having that we are strong, stronger than the Powers of the Dark.”
FIVE MORE REVIEWS BY URSULA K. LE GUIN
Ursula K. Le Guin was an acclaimed writer of science fiction and fantasy. I would say she's definitely the most influential American writer of her generation. I have fallen in love with her work many years ago and I'd never looked back!
READ MORE URSULA K. LE GUIN'S BOOK REVIEWS ON MY BLOG AND FIND YOUR NEXT PERFECT READ:
1. THE WORD FOR WORLD IS A FOREST (A NOVELLA)
This novella is an absolute masterpiece! Poetically written, profoundly serious and wonderfully imaginative, The Word for World is a Forest is an exceptional book. The story Le Guin created is a incredibly tragic and sad one, but it rings absolutely true in its sadness and tragedy. Wisdom is something I have come to expect in Ursula K.Le Guin's writing but this novella seems to be especially abundant in it. Wisdom is a big word, yet I cannot use another, for Le Guin's writing truly strikes me as wise. This novella ( or a short novel, depending how you classify it) is a work of great complexity that can be studied on many levels and that raises many interesting questions, from psychological, social, political to linguistic ones. The Word for World is a Forest captures the harsh realities of any war or military conquest and stresses that it is often (if not always) the innocents that suffer and die.
The Telling in the novel's title is actually a philosophy (or a religion if you will) based n Taoism. I loved Le Guin's take on Taoist inspired religion/philosophy know as 'The Telling' in the novel. It seems to me that Le Guin is well acquainted with Taoism and Buddhism, so well acquainted she is able to summon some of the complexity of Asian theologies, myths and philosophy in this novel, something I imagine is not easy to do. Sutty's sincere devotion to discovering and saving the forbidden semi-religion known as The Telling is very convincing, but Sutty as a protagonist is a bit underwhelming.
3. THE LEFT HAND OF DARKNESS (A NOVEL)
The Left Hand of Darkness is a brilliant novel set on a planet whose culture is quite different from our own. It questions gender identity in the most brilliant of ways. This is a novel way ahead of its time. One of the best novels I have ever read for sure!
Lindos atuendos. Me gusto mucho ese libro. Gracias por la reseña. Te mando un beso.
ReplyDeleteGracias
DeleteThat sounds like an interesting novel, thank you for the review! xxx
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome and thank you for your comment :).
DeleteThe novel seems to be very interesting. Thank you, Ivana. I hope you are feeling well.
ReplyDeleteIt's a fascinating novel.
DeleteOh, I always love how you love a book you have read. You do give us a journey indeed! Thanks for these inspiring outfits too. So lovely and sporty and great for the day and night, too. So cool!
ReplyDeleteIt's fun to wear something sporty sometimes. I don't often wear sporty outfits.
DeleteYou capture these characters so well. I am so glad you enjoy this author and bring us such an intense review! Awesome wardrobe too! You always give us a feel of your travels in what you wear. Amazing! Thank you for being so inspiring. Thank you for reading and your comments too! All the best to a lovely August!
ReplyDeleteThanks dear!
DeleteHello,
ReplyDeleteI had already realised that you are a super productive person, or a workaholic, sometimes this is not good because it is very stressful and stress can interfere with your illness! I draw a parallel between you and Tenar, perhaps you take your duty too seriously, and life needs to be taken more lightly! As for your evening looks, I'll start by telling you that I love photos with Greek columns! I love your yellow dress, it's one of my favourite colours, but all 4 looks are great for the evening in Mostar! Hugs beautiful Ivana!
I think I'm sometime stressed either way but I agree that it is important to find a good balance. Sometimes being busy with work helps me not to think of other things. Somehow it is important not to turn into a workaholic- that's not a good life to live.
DeleteThe Greek columns are very nice. They are located at Spanish square in Mostar.
I've lived both ways, with a lot of work and responsibility, and with no work at all, in the first case I missed out on other things that life gives us because I was busy! In the second case, I became ill because I went from 1000 to 0. As you say, there has to be a certain harmony between work and leisure! Work is important, but so is living!
DeleteYou're right, keeping our minds busy makes us forget other things, in my case it makes me forget the great disappointments I've suffered with important people in my life! But all that is in the past, now I'm living another life!
I can tell you really liked this book! Sounds like there's a bit of social criticism beneath all that fantasy.
ReplyDeleteThere is. Ursula criticizes human greed. She also explores the way society treats and limits women.
DeleteI really like you in this yellow dress :)
ReplyDeleteI love wearing yellow. I should do it more often.
DeleteBeautiful look! This looks like a fun palette! xx
ReplyDeleteI am your new visitor. My New Blog site. Please Visit Now.
https://tinyurl.com/oliviasfashionhouse2024
ok:)
DeleteGorgeous outfits and love the yellow dress :-D
ReplyDeleteIt's a fun dress!
Delete
ReplyDeleteYou look so happy, I really like the photos.
Every outfit is beautifully styled and suits you wonderfully <3
I apppreciate it!
DeleteI love your choices!
ReplyDeleteBeijos e Abraços,
BLOG | Instagram
I'm happy to hear that!
DeleteI like your outfits very much, Ivana!
ReplyDeleteSposibo!
DeleteVery interesting review! You've piqued my interest! Great styling, you look very pretty. :)
ReplyDeleteThank you!
DeleteHi dear, this novel seems to be so interesting, I really loved the review and you look fabulous in these outfits. Wonderful Post! Have a great day!
ReplyDeleteRampdiary
Thanks
DeleteBonitos vestidos y te quedan muy bien. Saludos.
ReplyDeleteGracias
DeleteGreat outfits, Ivana! I like the scarves worn at the waist - I need to do this! Thanks for the inspiration!
ReplyDeleteThe scarf worn as a belt is a great trick. I sometimes use it to mask bloating issues. :)
DeleteMe encanto la reseña del libro, se lee muy interesante y a esa autora no la conocia, pero por ti ya me llamo la atencion, por cierto me encanto el vestido azul cielo, saludos:D
ReplyDeleteGracias!
DeleteIt’s great to see such a detailed review of *The Tombs of Atuan*! Ursula K. Le Guin’s exploration of new characters and settings in this sequel adds a rich layer to the Earthsea series. Tenar’s journey and the contrast with Ged’s story offer a fresh perspective that's both intriguing and profound.
ReplyDeleteI just posted a new blog post www.melodyjacob.com, I invite you to read, Thank you.
Contrasts are very present in Ursula's writing. I think it comes from her fascination with Daoism/ Teoism and the ying-yang symbolism.
DeleteInteresting book and beautiful outfits!
ReplyDeleteHave a wonderful day:)
Dzijekuje.
DeleteSo many beautiful outfits.
ReplyDeleteThe book seems interesting to me.
Greetings Irma
I hope you'll enjoy it if you decide to read it.
DeleteYou put so much effort into your book reviews, I'm impressed that the central character was a woman and even if the genre isn't something that appeals to me, I'd probably buy the book for the cover alone!
ReplyDeleteGorgeous outfits, the white pleated dress especially! xxx
I do love writing book reviews!
DeleteThank you for sharing your book review and I love these summer outfits.
ReplyDeleteJulia x
https://www.thevelvetrunway.com/
I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it!
Delete